Welcome to the Science of Sport, where we bring you the second, third, and fourth level of analysis you will not find anywhere else.

Be it doping in sport, hot topics like Caster Semenya or Oscar Pistorius, or the dehydration myth, we try to translate the science behind sports and sports performance.

Consider a donation if you like what you see here!


Did you know?
We published The Runner's Body in May 2009. With an average 4.4/5 stars on Amazon.com, it has been receiving positive reviews from runners and non-runners alike.

Available for the Kindle and also in the traditional paper back. It will make a great gift for the runners you know, and helps support our work here on The Science of Sport.



Showing posts with label Twenty20 Cricket. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Twenty20 Cricket. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 03, 2007

Cricket - Twenty20 "fallout" - too much money, too much cricket?

The Twenty20 Cricket World Cup is now a thing of the past, seeming to have departed as quickly as it came, and as rapidly as a ball off Yuvraj's bat over a mid-wicket boundary.

The game continues to battle its way through the complexity of what this new and (potentially) improved version of the game offers. Recently, Malcolm Speed, Chief Executive of the International Cricket Council, declared that "We have a problem of fitting Twenty20 into the international calendar". This is of course true, there's too much cricket being played these days - the subject of our article further below. The point, however, is that Twenty20 offers a way to ease the congestion by reducing demands on players. More importantly, the ICC may face a problem of getting enough money to fund the game, if the market demand for the 20 over game reaches levels that detract from the 50-over game. It's a delicate problem, and the ICC hardly inspire confidence that they will handle it correctly.

In other cricket related news, before we get onto the main part of this post, the Indian Sports council face a difficult situation themselves. The Indian Cricket Board showered their victorius Indian cricketers with rewards valued at $3 million, including a Porsche for one player, houses for all of the them and massive financial rewards.

This did not go down too well with the Indian hockey team, who received virtually nothing after winning the Asian Hockey title a few months earlier. They protested this disparity in recognition and reward, since they perhaps wanted a Porsche or two themselves. They also claimed that they "were not jealous" but were "very proud of the Indian cricketers". So proud, in fact, that they threatened a hunger strike! I'm not entirely sure what the outcome of this was (or will be), but can you imagine if every NBA team and every NFL Quarterback refused to play or eat because he wasn't on the same salary package as the highest paid coach or player - world sport would be bankrupt!

The world game from a coach's point of view

The quote referred to earlier, from Malcolm Speed, suggests that the game's calendar presents one of the biggest problems for cricket coaches and managers. The calendar is simply too congested to allow Twenty20 matches, let alone proper physical preparation. In line with that, today we feature a guest post, from David Hinchcliffe, who runs the Harrowdrive cricket website. This site is an excellent resource for cricket coaching tips, drills and practice sessions and insights into the psychology and physiology of cricket - if you're involved in the game, be it as a player or a coach, it's a must read!

But David wrote the following piece on the preparation of cricketers. It is a general piece describing the implications of calendar congestion on the coaches and players of the modern game. According to David, the lack of time means that the 'correct' method of planning training goes out the window and so the risk of injury and burnout are much greater. David writes the following:

The traditional methods of creating a planned, periodised structure to training can't be applied any longer because there is no longer a defined off-season and no peak to work towards. On top of this, more players get injured or fatigued so squads need to be larger than ever. More players need to be at their peak for longer. However, nobody can peak all the time.

Due to this, support staff like strength and conditioning coaches have been forced to take a new approach in the fitness of international cricketers. The principles remain the same – accumulating fitness over time through progressive overload, specificity and adequate recovery. What has changed is the planning.

A good coach analyses what a player needs on an individual basis and builds a plan built on all the components needed for an elite performer – work capacity, strength, power, speed and mobility. A yearly (or longer) plan can then be split into 'blocks' of weeks where each component becomes the focus.

This way the whole year can be used to develop fitness without it impacting on a players game. That is where I consider the real art of a coach lies: Being able to prioritise fitness needs and fit complex training or recovery around games. This is especially true in test match series were players could be on the field for two days or equally be at a loose end for two days. The training would look very different in both circumstances.

This means planning needs to be less like a detailed blueprint and more like a general roadmap. Whether a player is successful or not may in part be dependant on whether the coach has been successful in his plan.


You can read more about the details and specifics of the training programme at Harrowdrive!

Ross

Saturday, September 22, 2007

South African cricket woes - Twenty20 meltdown

The World Twenty20 Championships is flying by. As I write this, the first semi-final is about to begin, followed almost immediately by the second and then the final tomorrow. It seems like just two weeks ago that this tournament began. Oh, hang on, it did! I recall the 50-Over World Cup earlier this year, lasting all of 55 days! This two week tournament has been a breath of fresh air.

Not quite a breath of fresh air was South Africa's performance the other night. The afore-mentioned first semi-final, about to begin features Pakistan against NEW ZEALAND. Not South Africa, and we had all taken for granted that we were there. In fact, many South Africans had probably not even considered the possibility that we would not win the trophy, let alone make the semi-finals. But, in the words of Graeme Smith, "I guess we do find ways to get out of these tournaments... It's very disappointing knowing you've lost only one game in the tournament and you're out... That does seem a little bit weird" (More on this later)

The post-mortems have been done, and done extensively, as one might expect considering South Africa's history of such performances at major tournaments. You can read these articles and discussions around SA cricket at the following links:

Bitter pill for SA cricket fans
South African cricket chokers - IOL
South Africa choke on their lines again - Cricinfo

One thing that I would like to emphasize, in defence of South Africa, is that the outcome of these Twenty20 game s is tenuous at best. The margins for error are so small, the difference between winning and losing so tiny, that to have thought we were guaranteed to make the semi-final was presumptious to begin with.

Some of the reaction to this loss is therefore slightly over the top - this kind of loss could happen to anyone - ask Australia, who have had some incredibly embarassing Twenty20 losses (a hiding against England and the Zimbabwe game come to mind). Twenty20 cricket can be a game of 'all or nothing', the difference between 200 for 4 and 120 all out is perhaps three or four critical balls in the innings. But the nature of the game makes the comments of Smith after the final all the more irrelevant and concerning.

In the post match interview, Smith pointed out that this was South Africa's first loss and now we are out. He called this situation "a little weird". What does this have to do with anything? Yes, granted, the format of the tournament meant that certain matches were, to be blunt, irrelevant (Australia-Zimbabwe turned out to be one such match - a warmup game and wake-up call for Australia, and then they go on to win the games that matter). But South Africa knew the game against India was not irrelevant, they knew precisely what needed to be done and at this juncture, they could not do it. So looking back and reminding the 'gullible' South African fan that we lost only once is patronizing.

The fact is, that loss was so bad it saw us plummet from first to third, when only two go through. The design of this competition was always going to create 'knock-out' matches in the back end of the Super 8 phase. Australia and Sri Lanka played out what was basically a quarterfinal in Cape Town. Australia won by 10 wickets. South Africa didn't even have to win, but they failed to lose well enough to even make the next game, so to remind us of the fact that we beat Bangladesh, England, the West Indies (who couldn't be anyone) and New Zealand is really irrelevant.

The second thing Smith pointed out is that up to this point, we've been the best team in the tournament and had played good cricket. This too, is irrelevant, because as any sportsman knows, you're "only as good as your last game" (to use a cliche).

But more to the point, it isn't true. It seems to me, and I say this at risk of being called unpatriotic, that South Africans, more than anyone else, have an inflated sense of our own potential. We are world-beaters in our own minds, with a tendency to create invincibles out of mediocrity. This is most apparent in our long distance running, where our running fraternity celebrate 'world class' mediocrity almost every weekend. We enthuse over average performances, while the rest of the world get on with creating world class quality. Have we lost touch with reality?

This South African cricket team were in trouble against England, and were saved by basically three blows by Morkel and embarassing fielding from England. They were in trouble against New Zealand, saved by Kemp's big hitting and Billy Doctrove's umpiring. And yes, a hall mark of a good team is that they can win from difficult situations. But not all the time. An umpiring decision here or there, a dropped catch, a risk that pays off or fails, and you have a different game, so you can never rely on your past as a sign that your future will be good too. Past performance does not predict future performance, sorry to say. And so three games in a row was a game too far for our middle order to rescue the team. So when Smith points out that we played the best cricket of the tournament, he'd do well to remember that perhaps Sri Lanka felt the same way, until their wheels came off. Heck, Bangladesh probably felt they were unlucky to lose a couple of games here and there. The same thing happened in 1999, where we felt we were the best team in the tournament, even though it was Lance Klusener who had to rescue us from near impossible situations almost every game. Eventually, he couldn't, and we felt robbed. Truth is, any other tournament, we'd have been eliminated long before the semi-finals.

Few people learn from success. Australia has, in the past, used success as a platform to build more success. There is a saying in war, which I recall reading once, that you never send a messenger on the same route twice, even if he was successful the first time, because once a route's been used, the enemy is onto it. Chances are, sending him out there the second time would fail. And that mentality - innovate while winning, is what has given Australia near-invicibility in the last 10 years. South Africa, on the other hand, seem to run the same template over and over, even when it fails. So while Australia seems to learn from success, we appear to be struggling to learn from our failures. Perhaps this latest episode will turn that around...

Ross

Monday, September 17, 2007

Arena Football - Lessons for Twenty20?

Southern-hemisphere nations and other rugby lovers are probably familiar with American, sometimes called "Gridiron," football. The National Football League (NFL) is a dominant entity in professional sports in the USA, and the league is a money-making behemoth for the cartel of team owners, the players, and even for a number of peripheral merchants and entrepreneurs who benefit from the league activities.

The NFL was formed in 1920 by eleven teams, and currently has 32 teams on its log. Most will agree that the modern era of the league began in 1966 when the rival American Football League merged with the NFL. This year also saw the inaugural Super Bowl, which subsequently has become to represent the pinnacle of sports marketing. Ratings are so high for this one match, that reportedly during the 2006 match a 30 second ad spot cost $2.5 million!

Particularly from the birth of the Super Bowl, the game has continued to grow and rake in more and more revenue. In spite of this, a former league executive sparked an idea that he thought would make money, and in 1987 Jim Foster launched the Arena Football League. The similarities between the NFL and the AFL are comparable to those between Test cricket and Twenty20, and therefore it is interesting for us to examine where Arena football has gone in its first twenty years.

Since its inception in 1987, Arena football has grown to 19 teams. The style of play is meant to be faster and more exciting, and there are some differences in the rules that help to promote this type of play. However most of the equipment and rules are very similar to the NFL and it is rather the smaller field that encourages faster and more explosive plays. For rugby fans, there is even a drop kick option worth two points!

The AFL has made great strides in the last twenty years. Just surviving in the American sports market would have been enough, but AFL has grown its fan base over the years and added more and more teams. Going into is 22nd season, gate receipts are healthy and the league continues to show growth---over two million fans attended games last season.

So does the success of the AFL bode well for Twenty20? That, my friends, is the one million dollar question, although information on the AFL is scarce (we could not find much about its revenue growth over the years). Over its life the AFL has had a total of 47 different franchises, but currently has 19 active ones. That means that teams have come and gone, some staying around for only 2-3 years before folding. This suggests that the league employs a business model that allows self-preservation in spite of losing teams occasionally.

We know that Major League Soccer (MLS) adopted and still employs a conservative management plan. It dictates that the league owns the teams and therefore distributes the wealth more evenly among its teams. Player contracts are also negotiated by the league, and not the individual teams. A massive disparity in wealth distribution and over expansion saw the downfall of the old North American Soccer League (NASL) (1968-1984) as the poorer teams could not keep up with the richer teams. The conservative approach of MLS has seen it survive for 12 years, and that bodes well for its future in the tough (and saturated) American market. However, MLS reportedly has lost $350 million since its inception, and although profitability is said to be near, MLS is still a break even or money losing operation.

So Twenty20, if it is to survive and grow, must adopt a business model that takes into account the obstacles that it will face in its infant years. the excitement is high now around the inaugural World Cup, but then again the world champs of most sports always draw more interest. The challenge now will be how Twenty20 manages and promotes regular play between countries. With cricket's bad record of seemingly inept management, perhaps the challenge is greater than normal?

Good luck Twenty20!


Friday, September 14, 2007

Twenty20 Cricket - the debate continues

Yesterday's article looking at the evolution of Twenty20 cricket provoked some interesting comments from readers. Some feel that the Twenty20 game is the only one worth watching, while others see no problem at all. So clearly, this issue is one that polarizes opinion.

Some of those comments have been quite thought provoking and in this follow up article, I thought I'd address some of those issues very briefly.

Different strokes for different folks

The first, and one of the most interesting comments comes from David, who is the author of the Harrow Drive cricket website. He's pointed out that in the UK, first class (4 day) crowds are totally different from Test match crowds. These are of course completely different from Twenty20 crowds and 50-over crowds. So the 3 versions of the game cater to very different markets. In that case, there'd be no problem. The analogy from marketing is that a potential buyer of luxury cars (Audi, BMW, Mercedes) is a very different market to the buyer of a student car (Opel Corsa, Golf, Toyota etc). And so competition is relatively low, because they are competing for different markets.

Whether this is exactly the case is debatable, I suppose. Twenty20 is so new that it's impossible to tell whether it will gradually alter the demographics of the average cricket fan. In other words, the current Test match enthusiast is someone who grew up without Twenty20 cricket. In 15 years time, will the fan who has grown up on Twenty20 take to tests in the same way? I'm not sure...I'd like to think that the tradition, strategy and skill (more than just technical) aspects of tests will appeal to a crowd that will not be too easily influenced by the crash-bang-wallop of Twenty20 cricket. As one fan has written "I think there are still more than enough fans who prefer a Kallis cover drive to a Symonds slog over cow corner". This spectator will always admire the subtleties of test cricket.

The influence of the sub-continent on the future of the game

But the one thing that no one has really considered is the influence of the sub-continent on the future of the game. Becaus like it or not, the sub-continent, and particular India, hold cricket in the depths of its wallet, so to speak. Most of the game's money comes from India, and it's no co-incidence that all the ICC sponsors are companies that have major presence in India. TV rights are worth much more when India plays than any other country.

In fact, so dominant is the Indian presence of the game, that the country with the second most cricket viewers in the world is the USA - made up of Indian immigrants on the eastern seabord! But Twenty20 cricket was born in England and South Africa, and though it's played in India, it hasn't quite caught on there. If it does, however, then suddenly the money that might be thrown at it would certainly threaten the 50-over game at least. Indeed, this is already threatening to happen, with the much spoken about 'rebel' league that got Andrew Hall into the headlines recently. The bottom line, if you'll pardon the pun, is the bottom line and if Twenty20 cricket seems more attractive to the bottom line in India, then the ICC might struggle to contain it.

I'm sure there's a great deal of discussion still to be had on this issue. And ultimately, only time will tell. It will be interesting to see how domestic competitions in India are affected as a result of the 20-over game, and what it does for Test matches. Difficult situation for the ICC though, although as I wrote previously, I believe that Twenty20 presents an opportunity to grow the game. It's just a question of strategy.

Ross

Wednesday, September 12, 2007

Twenty20 Cricket - will it kill off "real" cricket?

It's only been two days, but the Twenty20 Cricket tournament has almost surpassed the excitement levels achieved through the ENTIRE snooze-fest of the 50-over World Cup in the West Indies earlier this year. That tournament was beset by problems, ranging from poor attendances, off-field incidents, and let's face it, boring cricket. Last night's opening match between SA and the West Indies suggests that the next 2 weeks will be anything but boring.

And therein lies the problem. Twenty20, Pro20, call it what you will, is proving so popular that there is almost a danger that it will 'cannabilize' its own brand. After all, once you've experienced cricket on amphetamines, who'd go back to the tranquilizers? And so a lot has been written and debated about whether the introduction of Twenty20 cricket will in fact kill off the 50-over game, and, GASP, test match cricket!

Recently, Sports Illustrated featured this question, and without really coming to a conclusion, presented both sides of the argument. One is that the game is so exciting that it will bring fans back to the game and that can only be good for Tests and 50-over contests. The alternative, as mentioned, is that it's so exciting it makes 50-Over cricket seem like school detention on a Friday afternoon in summer, and so will kill the game off.

When you speak to the current and former players, they take the approach of saying either that:
  • It's good for the game because it will teach players new skills and improve existing ones, because the game is so different, it takes innovation to succeed, and that's good for the game;
  • It's bad for the game because players will become lazy and sloppy and learn bad habits, which will negatively affect the longer versions of the game.

So it seems no one can agree on this one. Good or bad? Here at The Science of Sport, we thought we'd throw our hat into the ring as well. Admittedly, this is not our usual fare (there's little direct "science" in evaluation of this debate), but from a sports management point of view (my particular interest), there are a couple of things that maybe haven't been looked at in as much detail yet.

The first is the question (and this comes from science). The trick is to ask the right question. People have been asking "Does Twenty20 cricket compete with 50-Over and Test match cricket?. I don't believe this is the question that should be asked. Or, perhaps stated differently, I believe this is only 5% of the question that should be asked. The real question should be "What competition does cricket currently face (without Twenty20) that might affect its future?"

Because when you ask this question, then you begin to see that 50-over cricket and Test Match cricket are already in danger of being swallowed up in a world where sport is no longer sport - it's entertainment. And from this point, you can begin to see that Twenty20 cricket may in fact be the only thing that can save cricket. The competition for 50-Over cricket is not Twenty20 cricket, it's Playstations, Nintendo Wiis, X-boxes. It's DVD's and movies and shopping malls, and the internet.

And so a 12-year old boy, who lives in Sandton, is not faced with a dilemma over whether to go watch a 50-Over match rather than a Twenty20 match - his dilemma is whether he should play Tombraider or Gran Turismo? Should he go watch Die Hard 4.0 or just hang out in Sandton? Given that choice, cricket was losing to begin with. But what Twenty20 cricket does is it introduces a new market to children that just gives the longer versions of the game a better chance of capturing that young talent before it is swallowed up by the world of computer technology and fast-food entertainment.

So a lot of experts and commentators have touched on the fact that the Twenty20 game must be good because it brings fans into grounds. Even more importantly, it brings children to the game - future players are being created by Twenty20 cricket. I have no doubt that in the next 15 years, at least one South African cricket star will be interviewed on TV and say that his first cricket memory was watching South Africa beat the West Indies in a 20-Over match at the Wanderers. Without Twenty20 cricket, that player may have disappeared from the sports world completely.

Now, all is not rosy, just because children are back in the game. There is of course, the issue of how to manage Twenty20 cricket. Sponsors and broadcasters, who provide most of the revenue for the sport (and therefore call the shots, unfortunately) are obviously lining up for this new and exciting "product". The bodies controlling cricket must be careful they do not over commit to selling it at the expense of the other versions. But most of all, what needs to be done is that structures must be created that move young cricketers from the Twenty20 game to the Test match game smoothly. If the ICC had any foresight, then, they would be planning a marketing campaign to channel players from 20-overs to test matches. Forget about trying to bring the players in at the 50-over and Test match level. Few children will choose an 8-hour match over a 3-hour one, especially when it's only about half as exciting. But as they mature, then the introduction of these longer versions may even be appealing. So Twenty20 is not the enemy, it is a possible feeder system, and powers-that-be should proactively be using it.

That's about it for this particular discussion. My (Ross) management background made this a topic too interesting to leave alone. But over the next few weeks, we'll be looking a lot more at the science of cricket, so join us for that!

Ross